Football’s Concussion Crisis Is Awash With Pseudoscience

De Transcription | Bibliothèque patrimoniale numérique Mines ParisTech
Révision datée du 27 novembre 2025 à 07:22 par GregoryLloyd4 (discussion | contributions)
(diff) ← Version précédente | Voir la version actuelle (diff) | Version suivante → (diff)
Aller à : navigation, rechercher


All products featured on WIRED are independently chosen by our editors. However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or Alpha Brain Clarity Supplement from purchases of merchandise by these links. Football’s concussion downside has spawned an enormous market of questionable options-unproven supplements, mouth guards claiming to guard in opposition to brain trauma, a collar marketed as "bubble wrap" for a player’s mind. If solely preventing mind trauma had been that straightforward. Whether in an effort to avoid wasting the sport and players’ brains or in a cynical ploy to revenue off the fear of parents and gamers, the market for concussion technologies is booming. An eagerness to "do something" has led individuals to adopt or promote some fairly dubious merchandise, says Kathleen Bachynski, an assistant professor of public health at Muhlenberg College. In a paper revealed in July, she and her colleague James Smoliga documented the rising availability of pseudoscientific concussion products. The Federal Trade Commission has also been monitoring bogus claims. In 2012 it prohibited a company known as Alpha Brain Clarity Supplement-Pad from claiming its mouth guard can scale back the chance of concussion.



The FTC additionally warned 18 different companies about their products, together with a dietary complement endorsed by New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady and marketed by his enterprise accomplice Alejandro Guerrero that promised to protect towards concussions by offering a kind of "seat belt" for the mind. The supplement was eventually discontinued. But new products proceed to crop up, making claims that go beyond the proof. These technofixes face a tough problem: the legal guidelines of physics. When your head will get yanked round, your mind does too, and it’s nearly inconceivable to decouple the two. "You can’t put a seat belt around the mind," says Adnan Hirad, a graduate scholar on the University of Rochester who has achieved research on mind accidents in soccer gamers. Concussions happen when the pinnacle abruptly accelerates or decelerates, pressing the brain toward the skull-think of how an astronaut gets pushed into their seat when a rocket takes off, or how a passenger will get thrown against the sprint if the automobile makes a sudden stop.



With sufficient pressure, the mind can slam the inside of the skull, but what happens more generally is the power of the motion stretches the nervous tissue, impairing the ability of neurons to fireplace properly, says Steven Broglio, director of the Michigan Concussion Center in Ann Arbor. Rotation of the pinnacle seems to cause extra brain stretching and deformation than just straight again-and-forth motions, says Mehmet Kurt, a mechanical engineer at Stevens Institute of Technology. Because there’s no good solution to see what’s occurring in the mind when someone gets dinged on the top, researchers are left to examine the aftermath. "What’s puzzling about concussions is that the symptoms can differ rather a lot," Kurt says. "Most of the time when a player has a concussion, commonplace medical imaging strategies don't show harm," he says, and that makes it impossible to diagnose with any one take a look at. Instead, a doctor conducts a clinical exam to assess the patient’s signs and makes a judgement call.



And the fear about head injuries isn’t nearly concussions, however about chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE, a neurodegenerative illness characterized by reminiscence loss, cognitive issues, and mood disorders, among different issues. "It’s close to settled science that CTE is attributable to repetitive head blows and never by single concussions," Hirad says. The current considering is that even sub-concussive hits can contribute, which means stopping concussions alone won’t eradicate the chance. Earlier this year, Hirad’s analysis group reported a stark discovering. After a single season of play, collegiate football players ended up with much less midbrain white matter than they’d started with. Using accelerometers mounted to the players’ helmets, the scientists noticed that the diploma of white matter loss correlated with how a lot rotational acceleration the players’ brains had experienced. The study reinforces the idea that rotational forces are particularly dangerous, Hirad says. The finding also underscores the boundaries of current helmet know-how.